438 Silver Hollow Road, Chichester, NY 12416 (MLS # 20265296)

Idyllic vintage cabins near Phoenicia have become increasingly hard to find, particularly at an attainable price. This warm and highly livable 1950 cabin sits almost squarely between Hunter and Belleayre, putting either mountain about twenty minutes away, while Phoenicia is less than ten minutes down the road. Its location near the end of Silver Hollow is another part of the draw. One of the most sought-after roads in the Chichester/Phoenicia area, it winds alongside Warner Creek with mountains rising all around. The house is also outside of the mapped floodplain. There is still time to be settled in before ski season. Inside, the open floor plan centers on a remarkably generous main room that feels far larger than expected in a house of 783 square feet. There is plenty of space for cooking, dining, hanging out and long conversations by the stove. Rich knotty pine paneling wraps the room, while windows on multiple sides bring in abundant natural light. The centerpiece is an exquisite fieldstone fireplace, its gorgeous masonry a tangible link to the cabin's past. On the hearth sits a wonderfully quirky barrel-shaped wood stove - part workhorse, part conversation piece, and exactly the sort of oddball detail that gives this place its soul. Primary heat is propane forced air, making this a cabin to enjoy in every season. The kitchen retains its original custom 1950s cabinetry, including glass-front cupboards and built-ins that combine craftsmanship with genuine utility. A classic Dutch door adds another memorable touch. Just beyond, a window-lined enclosed porch with a Catskills bluestone floor is made for slow mornings, reading, drawing or watching the wildlife. Practical features include a dedicated workshop, a new gas range and refrigerator, brand-new durable Pergo flooring and a backup generator already in place. Outside, towering pines, perennial plantings and old stonework give the property a loose, unstudied beauty, with a mountain ridge rising beyond the house. A generous bluestone patio, lawn and firepit create an almost woodland-courtyard atmosphere for friends and evenings outdoors. The separate shed is windowed and insulated, with double doors and a partly finished interior that could become a studio, special hideout or backyard think tank. Neighboring Phoenicia provides fun and funky year-round arts and culinary scenes, while hiking, fishing, swimming and the forever-wild reaches of the Catskill Park are all close at hand. For anyone who has been waiting for a Catskills place that feels authentic, personal and just a little unexpected, this may be it. #cabincore #cabininthewoods #midcenturycabin #hippiehouselove #wearestardust #chichestercabin #phoeniciacabin #catskillscabin

Last Updated	9/28/2026	Year Built	1950
Community	Shandaken	County	Ulster

SCHOOLS

Elementary School	Bennett 4-6

Price History

Prior to Sep 28, '26	$299,000
Sep 28, '26 - Today	$279,000

Additional Details

AIR	Ceiling Fan(s)
AIR CONDITIONING	Yes
APPLIANCES	DRYER, Electric Water Heater, Gas Range, RANGE, REFRIGERATOR, WASHER
AREA	Shandaken
BASEMENT	Crawl Space, Yes
CONSTRUCTION	Wood Siding
EXTERIOR	Fire Pit, Garden, Rain Gutters, Storage
HEAT	FORCED AIR, Propane, Wood Stove
INTERIOR	Built-in Features, Natural Woodwork, Open Floorplan
LOT	0.25 acre(s)
LOT DESCRIPTION	Cleared, LANDSCAPED, LEVEL, Native Plants
LOT DIMENSIONS	0.25
PARKING	Driveway
STORIES	1
STYLE	CABIN
TAXES	2409
UTILITIES	Cable Available, Electricity Connected
VIEW	Yes
VIEW DESCRIPTION	Mountain(s)
WATER	Private, Well

Location

 

Contact us about this Property

---